The total you see for your dates is the total you pay — taxes included.

Callahan Shore Rentals

Matt and Erin Callahan rent the beach houses their families have kept on the Outer Cape for three generations.

4.020 reviews12 listingsSelling since 2025Wellfleet, Massachusetts
An independent shopTalk to the sellerSecure checkout

Callahan Shore Rentals

July and August book Saturday to Saturday.

TOP OF THE SHOP

Bay flats houseTOP RATEDBay flats house$355.00★5.0 (1)A house on the bluff over Wellfleet's bay flats, with a porch facing west and stairs down to the beach. At low tide you can walk out for an hour. It is a sandy-feet kind of house: easy to live in, with an outdoor shower and beach chairs in the shed. It sleeps 6 across three bedrooms with 3 beds. Bay beaches, salt marsh and shingled villages from Falmouth out to the dunes of the Outer Cape.

All listings

12 listings · 12 available now

MEET THE SELLER

Callahan Shore Rentals, making in Wellfleet

From the shop

Matt and Erin Callahan rent the beach houses their families have kept on the Outer Cape for three generations.

12

Listings in the shop

2025

Selling since

4.0

From 20 verified reviews

Ask about a listing

What buyers say

4.0★★★★★

Across 20 reviews from verified buyers

5★10
4★4
3★1
2★5
1★0
★★★★★Ivo PetrovOct 22, 2026Verified

Great stay overall — the road in is a bit rough after rain, so take it slowly.

★★★★★Gus LindqvistOct 21, 2026Verified

One of the best stays we've had anywhere. Quiet, comfortable, beautifully kept, and Matt answered every question within the hour.

★★★★★Cleo ParkOct 20, 2026Verified

One of the best stays we've had anywhere. Quiet, comfortable, beautifully kept, and Matt answered every question within the hour.

Shop policies

Each place has a cancellation policy — flexible, moderate or strict — shown before you book and kept with your reservation. Cleaning and taxes are refunded in full whenever you cancel before check-in.

More shops to explore

Other independent shops on Hearthwood